Re: [hobbit] Hobbit bbtest-net crashing

[Henrik "Størner" <henrik (at) hswn.dk>]

In <A3D12FAD74FC8B46991703F40C182BABA20D5B4F (at) permls102.wde.woodside.com.au> "Everett, Vernon" <Vernon.Everett (at) woodside.com.au> writes:

>--_000_A3D12FAD74FC8B46991703F40C182BABA20D5B4Fpermls102wdewoo_
>Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii"
>Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable

>Below are our 5 most recent cores.
>And the corresponding entry in the bb-network.log file where available. (No=
>t all generate the entry in the log file)

It seems the problems occur in the C-ARES library which is used for
hostname lookups (via DNS).

Hobbit 4.2.0 uses version 1.2.1 of C-ARES; the current version is 1.5.3.
Unfortunately there's been a small change of the C-ARES API, so we cannot
just drop version 1.5.3 of the library into Hobbit 4.2.0. But it would
be nice to know if the problem is still there in the latest version.

If you want to try that, you can grab version 1.4.0 from 
http://c-ares.haxx.se/c-ares-1.4.0.tar.gz and then change Hobbit's
build/Makefile.rules: The "ARESVER" setting should be "1.4.0".
Then "make clean; rm -rf bbnet/c-ares/* bbnet/libcares.*; make"
and copy bbnet/bbtest-net to ~hobbit/server/bin/

If you want to try out the 1.5.3 version, drop me a mail and I'll
send you the patches needed for this to compile with Hobbit 4.2.0.



>Colin, our Linux man, and part-time C hacker, had this to say

>---snip---
>[root (at) las006 tmp]# gdb ~hobbit/server/bin/bbtest-net
>(gdb) l *0x42493a
>0x42493a is in ares_free_hostent (ares_free_hostent.c:35).
>30        free(host->h_name);
>31        for (p =3D host->h_aliases; *p; p++)
>32          free(*p);
>33        free(host->h_aliases);
>34        free(host->h_addr_list[0]);
>35        free(host->h_addr_list);
>36        free(host);
>37      }
>(gdb)


>line 31: Make 'p' equal to the memory address of host->h_aliases, check tha=
>t pointer p is not null and increment p
>line 32: free the memory pointed at by 'p'
>
>The problem here is that you check p then free p++.  My C is quite rusty bu=
>t I'd hazard a guess and say line 31 should read like:
>31        for (p =3D host->h_aliases; *(p++);)

Nope, sorry - Colin needs to revisit his C programming manual.
The "for" loop construct in line 31-32 will do the "p++" AFTER doing
the "free(*p)". 

Another way of writing the same code would be

   for (i=0; *(host->h_aliases[i]); i++)
   	free(host->h_aliases[i]);

where it is perhaps clearer that this goes through an array of
host aliases until there's an empty alias (this indicates 
the end of the array), and frees the memory used to record 
each alias. But again, the counter (i) is incremented AFTER
the "free" is done.

The code is a bit obscure, but I think it's correct (didn't write it
myself, though ...) I'm afraid the data structures used for hostname 
lookups weren't written to be easy to understand.



Regards,
Henrik